
Intrinsic Value — What a Halal Business Is Actually Worth
Last week we did the hard work of calculating owner earnings — the real cash a business throws off, not the accountant's version of profit. This week we answer the question that owner earnings exists to serve: what is the business actually worth?
Here is the trap most halal investors fall into. The screen tells you a company is permissible — low debt, clean revenue, no interest-heavy balance sheet. So you buy it. But "halal" tells you what you are allowed to own. It says nothing about whether you are paying a fair price. A wonderful, perfectly permissible business bought at twice its worth is still a bad investment. Halal is the entry ticket. Value is the game.
Intrinsic value, in one sentence
The intrinsic value of a business is the cash it will hand its owners over its remaining life, brought back to what that stream is worth today. That is the whole idea. Everything else — the spreadsheets, the models, the jargon — is just an attempt to estimate that one number without fooling yourself.
You do not need a discounted cash flow model with fifteen assumptions to do this. In fact, the more moving parts you add, the easier it is to hide a bad guess behind a precise-looking answer. We are going to do the opposite: a deliberately simple method you can run in fifteen minutes and actually defend.
The owner-earnings yield method
Start with the owner earnings figure you already know how to calculate. Now flip the usual question around. Instead of asking "what multiple should this trade at?", ask: "if I bought the whole company today at its market price, what cash yield would I earn?"
That number is your owner-earnings yield:
Owner Earnings Yield = Annual Owner Earnings ÷ Market Capitalisation
If a business generates $50 million in owner earnings and the whole company is priced at $700 million, your yield is about 7.1%. Now you have something you can reason about. Compare it to what you could earn elsewhere, and to how reliable those earnings are. A business with a durable competitive moat earning a steady 7% is worth far more than a fragile one earning a shaky 9%, because you can trust the first number to still be there in ten years.
Turning yield into a fair value
Once you know the yield a business should earn for its quality, you can work backwards to what it is worth. Decide the yield you would demand to own it, then divide:
Fair Value = Annual Owner Earnings ÷ Required Yield
Say our business earns $50 million in owner earnings, and given its moat and consistency you would happily accept a 6% yield to own it. Fair value is $50m ÷ 0.06 = about $833 million. Demand more for a shakier business — an 8% required yield drops fair value to $625 million. Notice what is happening: you are not predicting the future in fine detail. You are making two honest judgements — how much cash it produces, and how much you trust that cash — and letting the arithmetic do the rest.
For a business that is genuinely growing, you can nudge the required yield down a little to reflect earnings that will be larger next year. But be stingy with this. Growth you have to pay for in advance is the most expensive thing in investing, and the surest way to overpay. When in doubt, value the business on what it earns today, and treat future growth as a free option you did not pay for.
Then, and only then, the margin of safety
Here is the step that separates investing from hoping. Your fair value is an estimate, and estimates are wrong. So you never pay full fair value. You apply a margin of safety — a discount that protects you when your judgement turns out to be too optimistic.
Take that $833 million fair value and haircut it by 30%. Your buy price is roughly $583 million. If the market is offering the company for less than that, you have a candidate. If it is offering it for $800 million, you do nothing — a fair business at a full price is not an opportunity, it is a waiting game. The margin of safety is not pessimism. It is the humility to admit your number might be off by a fifth in either direction, and to only act when even a wrong number would still leave you fine.
A worked example, start to finish
Imagine a permissible consumer-goods company. From the annual report you calculate $120 million in owner earnings. It has a strong brand and stable demand, so you require a 6.5% yield. Fair value comes to $120m ÷ 0.065 ≈ $1.85 billion. Apply a 30% margin of safety and your buy price is about $1.29 billion. The market is currently pricing the whole company at $1.1 billion. That is below your buy price, with room to spare — so this earns a place on your watchlist and deeper work on the quality of those earnings. Flip the market price to $1.9 billion and the same wonderful business is simply not for sale at a price that makes sense. Same company. Completely different decision. Price is what tells them apart.
The mistakes that quietly wreck this
- Using a single lucky year. One bumper year of owner earnings will flatter your value. Use a normalised figure — an average across three to five years, or a conservative mid-cycle estimate.
- Requiring too low a yield for a fragile business. The required yield is where quality enters the maths. A business without a moat should have to clear a much higher bar before you call it cheap.
- Skipping the margin of safety because you love the company. Conviction is earned on the business; discipline is applied to the price. Never let the first talk you out of the second.
- Confusing a low price with a bargain. A stock can fall 40% and still be expensive if the earnings behind it are collapsing faster. Value is price relative to worth, never price relative to last month.
The takeaway
Valuation is not fortune-telling and it is not a competition to build the fanciest model. It is three honest questions asked in order: How much cash does this business really produce? How much do I trust that number? And am I being offered it for meaningfully less than it is worth? Answer those with the owner-earnings figure you already know how to find, apply a margin of safety, and you have replaced hoping with a decision you can defend — which is the whole point of investing like an owner rather than a gambler.
Next week we will look at what to do once you own it — how to tell the difference between a business having a bad quarter and a business whose story has actually broken.
