
When a Legend's Portfolio Meets the Halal Screen
A reader asked me last week: "Can you just tell me which investor to follow so I can copy their picks?"
Fair question. So I took three of the most respected value investors alive, pulled their latest filings, and ran all 23 of their holdings through the same six-point screen I use on my own portfolio.
Here's what came back.
Three hard fails
Philip Morris — 5% of Terry Smith's Fundsmith Equity fund. Tobacco. There's no interpretation, no scholarly debate, no "it depends on the revenue mix." It fails on business activity and it fails cleanly.
GE Aerospace — 5.5% of AKO Capital's book. Flagged on business activity for defence exposure. This one has more nuance than tobacco, and reasonable scholars land in different places on defence. But you should know it's there before you own it.
Transocean — and this is the one worth sitting with.
Mohnish Pabrai has compounded at roughly 15% a year for two decades. He runs a concentrated book — three positions, that's it. Transocean is 32% of it.
Total debt is 103% of market cap. The AAOIFI-style limit is 30%. That's not a marginal breach. That's more than three times over.
The point I want to make
Pabrai is a better investor than me. Probably better than most people reading this. His record is real and I've learned a great deal from him.
And his largest position by a wide margin would not pass the first screen a Muslim investor has to run.
That's not a criticism of him. He isn't screening for halal compliance — that was never his mandate. It's an observation about what "just copy a great investor" actually means in practice. Their constraints aren't your constraints.
What passed
Of the 23, twenty made it through the business-activity and debt screens. Four of those — Visa, Mastercard, Intercontinental Exchange, Moody's — sit in the financial sector and need a closer look at revenue mix before you'd call them settled. Payment networks and exchange operators aren't automatically impermissible, but they aren't automatically fine either.
And every single one of the 23 still needs a manual check on non-permissible income. No automated tool reads that reliably out of the financial notes. Not mine, not anyone's.
The part most people skip
Passing the halal screen is the beginning of the work, not the end.
Alphabet scored highest of everything I ran — 89 out of 100 on business quality. Excellent moat, exceptional balance sheet, dependable growth. It's also trading about 34% above my fair-value range right now.
A wonderful business at the wrong price is still a poor investment. The halal screen tells you a business is permissible. The valuation work tells you whether it's worth owning today. You need both, and neither substitutes for the other.
The names that came through with both a strong quality score and a price below fair value were a much shorter list than the names that merely passed the halal screen. That gap is where most of the actual work lives.
So what do you do with all this?
Not copy anyone. Read them, learn the reasoning, then run the names through your own screen — because your screen has a constraint theirs doesn't.
That's the whole discipline. Every stock, every time, both lenses.
Rizal
I ran all 23 through the Barakah Stock Check app, which does the halal screen, six quality scores and the fair-value range in about ten seconds per ticker. It's free for three days if you want to run your own watchlist: barakahprofits.com/stock-check
Educational content, not financial advice. The halal screen is an automated estimate — confirm compliance with a scholar-reviewed screener before you invest. Holdings data from Q1 2026 filings; positions change.
